Version 27.3 by Ecaterina Valica on 2013/07/31 10:16
Show last authors
1 {{velocity}}
2 $xwiki.ssx.use("Improvements.WebHome")
3 $xwiki.ssx.use("Standards.WebHome")
4 {{/velocity}}
5
6 == Community Feedback ==
7
8 {{info}}
9 [UX][Iteration] (, 2013)
10 {{/info}}
11
12 (% class="clearfloats" %)
13 (((
14 )))
15
16 (% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
17 (((
18 == Proposal ==
19
20 {{toc start="3"/}}
21 )))
22
23 (% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
24 (((
25
26 == Problem ==
27
28 * Support for both workspace and wiki creation
29 * Related proposal [[Create Improvements>>Improvements.CreateImprovements]]
30
31 )))
32
33 (% class="clearfloats" %)
34 (((
35 )))
36
37 === Option A ===
38
39 {{info}}
40 Create Workspace in the Add Menu
41 Create Wiki in Administration
42 (separated)
43 {{/info}}
44
45 (% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
46 (((
47 {{error}}
48 Con:
49 * (+/-) Wiki creation more hidden (but is a rare action, done only by admins (advanced users) that are familiar to Administration)
50 {{/error}}
51
52 {{success}}
53 Pro:
54 * Separate User functionality (found in the menu) from Admin functionality (found in the Administration area)
55 {{/success}}
56 )))
57
58 (% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
59 (((
60 {{gallery}}
61 image:AddMenuWorkspace.png
62 image:WorkspaceMenuSubWiki.png
63 image:CreateWorkspace.png
64 image:WorkspacesIndex.png
65 image:WikiManager.png
66 {{/gallery}}
67 )))
68
69 (% class="clearfloats" %)
70 (((
71 )))
72
73 === Option B ===
74
75 {{info}}
76 Option in the create wizard: choose if you want a wiki or a workspace
77 (mixted)
78 {{/info}}
79
80 (% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
81 (((
82
83 {{error}}
84 Con:
85 * For normal users, the type area will contain just one item: Workspaces, being a bit redundant
86 * Duplicated functionality for admins: in the Create step and in the Administration (for the wiki details and users management)
87 {{/error}}
88
89 {{success}}
90 Pro:
91 * Only one concept: Wiki. The type will be implemented using templates.
92 * The type (templates) zone is extensible in case we will want to add a new one
93
94 {{/success}}
95
96 )))
97
98 (% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
99 (((
100 {{gallery}}
101 image:AddMenuWiki.png
102 image:WikiMenuSubWiki.png
103 image:CreateWikiOption.png
104 image:TypeOption.png
105 image:CreateWikiOptionSimpler.png
106 image:CreateWikiMembers.png
107 {{/gallery}}
108 )))
109
110 (% class="clearfloats" %)
111 (((
112 )))
113
114 === Option C ===
115
116 {{info}}
117 Add Menu: Wiki, Workspace
118 (mixted/modular)
119 {{/info}}
120
121 (% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
122 (((
123
124 {{error}}
125 Con:
126 * Mixing User functionality (the ability to create Workspaces) with Admin functionality (the ability to create Wikis)
127 * Confusing for users that don't know the difference between Wiki and Workspaces
128 * Crowding the menu with an option that is rarely used
129 {{/error}}
130
131 {{success}}
132 Pro:
133 * Customizable, we could have an option to disable one way of creating wikis or another
134 {{/success}}
135
136 )))
137
138 (% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
139 (((
140 {{gallery}}
141 image:AddMenuWikiWorkspace.png
142 image:CreateWorkspace.png
143 image:CreateWiki.png
144 {{/gallery}}
145 )))
146
147 (% class="clearfloats" %)
148 (((
149 )))