Last modified by Ecaterina Moraru on 2013/11/13 12:50
From version 35.1
edited by Ecaterina Moraru
on 2013/11/13 12:50
Change comment: Moved page to http://design.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Improvements/CreateWikiImprovements
To version 28.8
edited by Ecaterina Valica
on 2013/07/31 16:10
Change comment: There is no comment for this version

Summary

Details

Page properties
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,1 @@
1 -xwiki:XWiki.risherry
1 +XWiki.evalica
Content
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,187 @@
1 -{{warning}}Moved to [[design.xwiki.org:Improvements.CreateWikiImprovements>>http://design.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Improvements/CreateWikiImprovements]]{{/warning}}
1 +{{velocity}}
2 +$xwiki.ssx.use("Improvements.WebHome")
3 +$xwiki.ssx.use("Standards.WebHome")
4 +{{/velocity}}
5 +
6 +== Community Feedback ==
7 +
8 +{{info}}
9 +How to call a workspace? http://markmail.org/message/cehvpds5qmljq5f7 (Jul 30, 2013)
10 +[Proposal] Have Workspace by default in XE http://markmail.org/thread/h2cqbmu5evd2acqn (Jul 29, 2013)
11 +[VOTE] Integrate Workspaces by default in XWiki's default XAR http://markmail.org/thread/o6wfuvx5xab4bgdd (Jul 20, 2013)
12 +{{/info}}
13 +
14 +(% class="clearfloats" %)
15 +(((
16 +)))
17 +
18 +(% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
19 +(((
20 +== Proposal ==
21 +
22 +{{toc start="3"/}}
23 +)))
24 +
25 +(% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
26 +(((
27 +
28 +== Problem ==
29 +
30 +* Support for both workspace and wiki creation
31 +* Related proposal [[Create Improvements>>Improvements.CreateImprovements]]
32 +
33 +)))
34 +
35 +(% class="clearfloats" %)
36 +(((
37 +)))
38 +
39 +=== Option A ===
40 +
41 +{{info}}
42 +Create Workspace in the Add Menu
43 +Create Wiki in Administration
44 +(separated)
45 +{{/info}}
46 +
47 +(% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
48 +(((
49 +{{error}}
50 +Con:
51 +* (+/-) Wiki creation more hidden (but is a rare action, done only by admins (advanced users) that are familiar to Administration)
52 +{{/error}}
53 +
54 +{{success}}
55 +Pro:
56 +* Separate User functionality (found in the menu) from Admin functionality (found in the Administration area)
57 +{{/success}}
58 +)))
59 +
60 +(% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
61 +(((
62 +{{gallery}}
63 +image:AddMenuWorkspace.png
64 +image:WorkspaceMenuSubWiki.png
65 +image:CreateWorkspace.png
66 +image:WorkspacesIndex.png
67 +image:WikiManager.png
68 +{{/gallery}}
69 +)))
70 +
71 +(% class="clearfloats" %)
72 +(((
73 +)))
74 +
75 +=== Option B ===
76 +
77 +{{info}}
78 +Option in the create wizard: choose if you want a wiki or a workspace (subtype)
79 +(mixted)
80 +{{/info}}
81 +
82 +(% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
83 +(((
84 +
85 +{{error}}
86 +Con:
87 +* For normal users, the type area will contain just one item: Workspaces, being a bit redundant
88 +* Duplicated functionality for admins: in the Create step and in the Administration (for the wiki details and users management)
89 +{{/error}}
90 +
91 +{{success}}
92 +Pro:
93 +* Only one concept: Wiki. The type will be implemented using templates.
94 +* The type (templates) zone is extensible in case we will want to add a new one
95 +
96 +{{/success}}
97 +
98 +)))
99 +
100 +(% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
101 +(((
102 +{{gallery}}
103 +image:AddMenuWiki.png
104 +image:WikiMenuSubWiki.png
105 +image:CreateWikiOption.png
106 +image:TypeOption.png
107 +image:CreateWikiOptionSimpler.png
108 +image:CreateWikiMembers.png
109 +{{/gallery}}
110 +)))
111 +
112 +(% class="clearfloats" %)
113 +(((
114 +)))
115 +
116 +=== Option C ===
117 +
118 +{{info}}
119 +Add Menu: Wiki, Workspace
120 +(mixted/modular)
121 +{{/info}}
122 +
123 +(% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
124 +(((
125 +
126 +{{error}}
127 +Con:
128 +* Mixing User functionality (the ability to create Workspaces) with Admin functionality (the ability to create Wikis)
129 +* Confusing for users that don't know the difference between Wiki and Workspaces
130 +* Crowding the menu with an option that is rarely used
131 +{{/error}}
132 +
133 +{{success}}
134 +Pro:
135 +* Customizable, we could have an option to disable one way of creating wikis or another
136 +{{/success}}
137 +
138 +)))
139 +
140 +(% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
141 +(((
142 +{{gallery}}
143 +image:AddMenuWikiWorkspace.png
144 +image:CreateWorkspace.png
145 +image:CreateWiki.png
146 +{{/gallery}}
147 +)))
148 +
149 +(% class="clearfloats" %)
150 +(((
151 +)))
152 +
153 +=== Option D ===
154 +
155 +{{info}}
156 +Only one notion (wiki or subwiki)
157 +Workspaces defined as the 'Users Isolation' checkbox
158 +{{/info}}
159 +
160 +(% class="left column50 dashboardleft" %)
161 +(((
162 +
163 +{{error}}
164 +Con:
165 +*
166 +{{/error}}
167 +
168 +{{success}}
169 +Pro:
170 +*
171 +{{/success}}
172 +
173 +)))
174 +
175 +(% class="dashboardright right column50" %)
176 +(((
177 +{{gallery}}
178 +image:.png
179 +image:.png
180 +image:.png
181 +image:.png
182 +{{/gallery}}
183 +)))
184 +
185 +(% class="clearfloats" %)
186 +(((
187 +)))
AddMenuSubWiki.png
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -XWiki.evalica
Size
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -25.7 KB
Content
CreateSubWiki.png
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -XWiki.evalica
Size
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -90.4 KB
Content
CreateSubWikiMembersInitial.png
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -XWiki.evalica
Size
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -57.8 KB
Content
CreateSubWikiMembersLocal.png
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -XWiki.evalica
Size
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -69.1 KB
Content
CreateSubWikiMembersLocalActivator.png
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -XWiki.evalica
Size
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -13.5 KB
Content
CreateSubWikiMembersMore.png
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -XWiki.evalica
Size
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1 -66.8 KB
Content